| 1990-1997 | ||
| TOP FIVE TEAMS | ||
| Highest Average | ||
| 1st | Masontown Presbyterian | .502 |
| 2nd | Ambassadors for Christ | .479 |
| 3rd | Carmichaels Methodist #1 | .416 |
| 4th | Throckmorton Methodist #2 | .411 |
| 5th | Waynesburg Methodist "C" | .395 |
| Most Runs/Game Average | ||
| 1st | Masontown Presbyterian | 11.8 |
| 2nd | Ambassadors for Christ | 10.3 |
| 3rd | Carmichaels Methodist #1 | 9.4 |
| 4th | Throckmorton Methodist #2 | 9.2 |
| 5th | Waynesburg Methodist "C" | 7.4 |
| Most Total Bases | ||
| 1st | Carmichaels Methodist #1 | 2096 |
| 2nd | Masontown Presbyterian | 2014 |
| 3rd | Ambassadors for Christ | 1918 |
| 4th | Throckmorton Methodist #2 | 1784 |
| 5th | Waynesburg Baptist | 1608 |
| Most Hits | ||
| 1st | Masontown Presbyterian | 1664 |
| 2nd | Ambassadors for Christ | 1544 |
| 3rd | Carmichaels Methodist #1 | 1195 |
| 4th | Throckmorton Methodist #2 | 1144 |
| 5th | Waynesburg Methodist "C" | 1075 |
| Most Singles | ||
| 1st | Masontown Presbyterian | 1492 |
| 2nd | Ambassadors for Christ | 1312 |
| 3rd | Carmichaels Methodist | 980 |
| 4th | Throckmorton Methodist #2 | 910 |
| 5th | Waynesburg Methodist "C" | 852 |
| Most Doubles | ||
| 1st | Carmichaels Methodist #1 | 620 |
| 2nd | Ambassadors for Christ | 496 |
| 3rd | Throckmorton Methodist #1 | 377 |
| 4th | Waynesburg Baptist | 328 |
| 5th | Waynesburg Nazarene | 259 |
| Most Triples | ||
| 1st | Ambassadors for Christ "B" | 314 |
| 2nd | Spraggs Methodist | 297 |
| 3rd | Fairall Methodist | 255 |
| 4th | Throckmorton Methodist #2 | 243 |
| 5th | Clarksville Christian | 240 |
| Most Home Runs | ||
| 1st | Ambassadors for Christ "B" | 106 |
| 2nd | Jefferson Methodist | 82 |
| 3rd | Waynesburg Presbyterian | 78 |
| 4th | Waynesburg Nazarene | 71 |
| 5th | Waynesburg Methodist | 53 |
| Most Long Singles | ||
| 1st | Masontown Presbyterian | 127 |
| 2nd | Ambassadors for Christ | 119 |
| 3rd | Throckmorton Methodist #2 | 83 |
| 4th | Carmichaels Methodist | 79 |
| 5th | Waynesburg Methodist "C" | 68 |