| 2016-2017 | ||||||
| TOP FIVE INDIVIDUALS | ||||||
| Highest Average | ||||||
| Under Age 55 | Age 55 & Over | |||||
| 1st | Phil Westich | .538 | 1st | Chris Haines | .540 | |
| Bible Baptist #1 | Fairall Methodist #1 | |||||
| 2nd | Brandi Baker | .500 | 2nd | Buck Buchanan | .513 | |
| Jefferson Baptist | Greensboro Baptist | |||||
| 3rd | Cliff Whyte | .488 | 3rd | Phyllis Kamerer | .461 | |
| Fairall Methodist #1 | Spraggs Methodist | |||||
| 4th | Ryan Brownfield | .447 | 4th | Tim Tanner | .459 | |
| Oak View Methodist | Greensboro Baptist | |||||
| 5th | James Baker | .446 | 5th | Pat Westich | .447 | |
| Jefferson Baptist | Bible Baptist #1 | |||||
| Best Slugging Percentage | ||||||
| Under Age 55 | Age 55 & Over | |||||
| 1st | John Robinson | 1.100 | 1st | Clyde Shaffer | 1.055 | |
| Carmichaels Free Methodist | Crabapple Community | |||||
| 2nd | Tommy Bohan | 1.076 | 2nd | Ray Mallory | 1.038 | |
| Bible Baptist #2 | Greensboro Baptist | |||||
| 3rd | Cliff Whyte | .939 | 3rd | Tom Dorazio | .904 | |
| Fairall Methodist #1 | Waynesburg Methodist | |||||
| 4th | Christian Randolph | .931 | 4th | Rachie Teegarden | .895 | |
| Jefferson Baptist | Hewitt Presbyterian | |||||
| 5th | Bud Robinson | .900 | 5th | Chris Haines | .876 | |
| Carmichaels Free Methodist | Fairall Methodist #1 | |||||
| Most RBI | ||||||
| Under Age 55 | Age 55 & Over | |||||
| 1st | Tommy Bohan | 88 | 1st | Chris Haines | 87 | |
| Bible Baptist #2 | Fairall Methodist #1 | |||||
| 2nd | Scott Rhodes | 83 | 2nd | Delmas Carpenter | 80 | |
| Jefferson Baptist | Fairall Methodist #1 | |||||
| 3rd | Cliff Whyte | 75 | 3rd | Jeff Cree | 65 | |
| Fairall Methodist #1 | Waynesburg Methodist | |||||
| 4th | Nathan Westich | 74 | 4th | Ray Mallory | 60 | |
| Bible Baptist #1 | Greensboro Baptist | |||||
| 4th | Lydia Calix | 74 | 5th | Bob Ellsworth, Sr. | 54 | |
| Bible Baptist #1 | Jefferson Methodist #2 | |||||
| Most Total Bases | ||||||
| Under Age 55 | Age 55 & Over | |||||
| 1st | Tommy Bohan | 338 | 1st | Pat Westich | 269 | |
| Bible Baptist #2 | Bible Baptist #1 | |||||
| 2nd | Christian Randolph | 311 | 2nd | Chris Haines | 255 | |
| Jefferson Baptist | Fairall Methodist #1 | |||||
| 3rd | Sam Chahl | 282 | 3rd | Clyde Shaffer | 250 | |
| Bible Baptist #2 | Crabapple Community | |||||
| 4th | Cliff Whyte | 279 | 4th | Ray Mallory | 246 | |
| Fairall Methodist #1 | Greensboro Baptist | |||||
| 5th | Scott Durr | 250 | 5th | Rachie Teegarden | 238 | |
| Crosspoint Assembly Of God | Hewitt Presbyterian | |||||
| Most Hits | ||||||
| Under Age 55 | Age 55 & Over | |||||
| 1st | Phil Westich | 170 | 1st | Chris Haines | 157 | |
| Bible Baptist #1 | Fairall Methodist #1 | |||||
| 2nd | James Baker | 158 | 2nd | Pat Westich | 147 | |
| Jefferson Baptist | Bible Baptist #1 | |||||
| 3rd | Cliff Whyte | 145 | 3rd | Jeff Cree | 124 | |
| Fairall Methodist #1 | Waynesburg Methodist | |||||
| 4th | Sam Chahl | 137 | 4th | Buck Buchanan | 122 | |
| Bible Baptist #2 | Greensboro Baptist | |||||
| 5th | George Zentkovich | 120 | 5th | Bob Fuller | 118 | |
| Jefferson Methodist #2 | Jefferson Methodist #2 | |||||
| Most Singles | ||||||
| Under Age 55 | Age 55 & Over | |||||
| 1st | Phil Westich | 162 | 1st | Buck Buchanan | 115 | |
| Bible Baptist #1 | Greensboro Baptist | |||||
| 2nd | James Baker | 145 | 2nd | Bob Fuller | 114 | |
| Jefferson Baptist | Jefferson Methodist #2 | |||||
| 3rd | Wayne Kennison | 99 | 3rd | Phyllis Kamerer | 101 | |
| Jefferson Methodist #2 | Spraggs Methodist | |||||
| 3rd | Bill Chahl | 99 | 4th | Chris Haines | 99 | |
| Bible Baptist #2 | Fairall Methodist #1 | |||||
| 5th | Hailey Hickman | 93 | 5th | Jeff Cree | 95 | |
| Bethlehem Baptist | Waynesburg Methodist | |||||
| Most Doubles | ||||||
| Under Age 55 | Age 55 & Over | |||||
| 1st | Sam Chahl | 126 | 1st | Pat Westich | 56 | |
| Bible Baptist #2 | Bible Baptist #1 | |||||
| 2nd | Scott Durr | 62 | 2nd | Kathy Douglas | 27 | |
| Crosspoint Assembly Of God | Waynesburg Bible Chapel | |||||
| 3rd | Greg Calix | 55 | 3rd | Jan Dulaney | 24 | |
| Bible Baptist #1 | Spraggs Methodist | |||||
| 4th | Dawn Yeager | 53 | 4th | Otis Shaffer | 23 | |
| Waynesburg Methodist | Jefferson Methodist #2 | |||||
| 5th | 49 | 5th | Chris Haines | 20 | ||
| Deborah Westich | Fairall Methodist #1 | |||||
| Bible Baptist #1 | Charlotte Makel | |||||
| Hewitt Presbyterian | ||||||
| Most Triples | ||||||
| Under Age 55 | Age 55 & Over | |||||
| 1st | Tommy Bohan | 102 | 1st | Clyde Shaffer | 83 | |
| Bible Baptist #2 | Crabapple Community | |||||
| 2nd | Christian Randolph | 100 | 2nd | Ray Mallory | 81 | |
| Jefferson Baptist | Greensboro Baptist | |||||
| 3rd | Cliff Whyte | 61 | 3rd | Rachie Teegarden | 77 | |
| Fairall Methodist #1 | Hewitt Presbyterian | |||||
| 4th | John Robinson | 52 | 4th | Tom Dorazio | 67 | |
| Carmichaels Free Methodist | Waynesburg Methodist | |||||
| 4th | Ivan Robinson, III | 52 | 5th | Carl Hoy, Jr. | 64 | |
| Carmichaels Free Methodist | Spraggs Methodist | |||||
| Most Home Runs | ||||||
| Under Age 55 | Age 55 & Over | |||||
| 1st | Vinny Wolfe | 31 | 1st | Alberta Renner | 20 | |
| Jefferson Baptist | Fairall Methodist #1 | |||||
| 2nd | Belinda Kennedy | 24 | 2nd | Margaret Walkos | 19 | |
| Waynesburg Christian | Waynesburg Baptist | |||||
| 3rd | J.F. Blaker | 23 | 2nd | Arleta Brown | 19 | |
| Bethlehem Baptist | Waynesburg Christian | |||||
| 4th | Noah Haggerty | 21 | 2nd | Deb Bowser | 19 | |
| Waynesburg Methodist | Jefferson Methodist #1 | |||||
| 5th | Noah King | 20 | 5th | Rita Balaban | 17 | |
| Bethlehem Baptist | Oak View Methodist | |||||
| Most Long Singles | ||||||
| Under Age 55 | Age 55 & Over | |||||
| 1st | Phil Westich | 11 | 1st | Larry Douglas | 8 | |
| Bible Baptist #1 | Waynesburg Bible Chapel | |||||
| 2nd | James Baker | 10 | 2nd | Dorothy Cheek | 7 | |
| Jefferson Baptist | Crabapple Community | |||||
| 3rd | Alex Evanoff | 8 | 2nd | Otis Shaffer | 7 | |
| Waynesburg Methodist | Jefferson Methodist #2 | |||||
| 4th | Dalton Woods | 7 | 2nd | Buck Buchanan | 7 | |
| Fairall Methodist #1 | Greensboro Baptist | |||||
| 5th | Brandi Baker | 6 | 5th | 6 | ||
| Jefferson Baptist | ||||||
| Bill Chahl | ||||||
| Bible Baptist #2 | ||||||
| Hailey Hickman | Bob Fuller | |||||
| Bethlehem Baptist | Jefferson Methodist #2 | |||||
| Walker Smith | ||||||
| Bethlehem Baptist | ||||||
| Heather Sorrow | ||||||
| Waynesburg Bible Chapel | ||||||