| 2013-2014 | |
| TEAM TROPHIES | |
| Fellowship Night | |
| Tournament Winners | |
| Ashley Arbogast | Oak View Methodist |
| Dorothy Cheek | Crabapple Community |
| Scott Durr | Crosspoint Assembly Of God |
| Laci Ludrosky | Hewitt Presbyterian |
| Pearl Ludrosky | Hewitt Presbyterian |
| Paul Reggetz | Washington Street Methodist |
| Ivan Robinson, Jr. | Carmichaels Free Methodist |
| Renee Sahady | Jefferson Methodist |
| Vinny Wolfe | Jefferson Baptist |
| Carlton T. Calvert Memorial Award: | |
| (Awarded to the Team with the most players under age 25) | |
| Jefferson Baptist | |
| League Championship Trophies | |
| "C" Division Champion: | |
| Waynesburg Nazarene | |
| "C" DIVISION RUNNER-UP: Carmichaels Methodist | |
| "B" Division Champion: | |
| Bible Baptist #1 | |
| "B" DIVISION RUNNER-UP: Hewitt Presbyterian | |
| League Champion: | |
| Washington Street Methodist | |
| LEAGUE RUNNER-UP: Fairall Methodist | |