| 1985-1986 | ||||
| STANDINGS | ||||
| Rank | Team | W | L | Pct |
| #1 | Waynesburg Baptist | 67 | 11 | .859 |
| #2 | Greene Valley Presbyterian | 54 | 24 | .692 |
| #3 | Waynesburg Christian | 47 | 31 | .603 |
| #4 | Waynesburg Methodist | 47 | 31 | .603 |
| #5 | Oak View / Throckmorton Methodist | 45 | 33 | .577 |
| #6 | Clarksville Christian | 44 | 34 | .564 |
| #7 | Masontown Presbyterian | 39 | 39 | .500 |
| #8 | Pitt Gas | 39 | 39 | .500 |
| #9 | Carmichaels Methodist "A" | 37 | 41 | .474 |
| #10 | Spraggs Methodist | 34 | 44 | .436 |
| #11 | Ruff Creek Baptist | 30 | 48 | .385 |
| #12 | Jefferson Baptist | 30 | 48 | .385 |
| #13 | Carmichaels Methodist "B" | 24 | 54 | .308 |
| #14 | Marianna Christian | 10 | 68 | .128 |