| 2013-2014 | |
| SENIOR PLAYERS | |
| Joseph G. Conklin Memorial Award | |
| (Awarded to Players who turn age 70 during the season) | |
| Don Amon | Crabapple Community |
| Butch Brunell | Washington Street Methodist |
| George Crosby | Great Bethel |
| Bob Ellsworth, Sr. | Great Bethel |
| Bob Moore | Pine Bank Methodist |
| Bob Strope | Waynesburg Nazarene |
| All Senior Players: Age 70 and Over | |
| Doris Braun | Pine Bank Methodist |
| Howard Bungard | Crabapple Community |
| Alice Campbell | Carmichaels Free Methodist |
| Dorothy Cheek | Crabapple Community |
| Barb Colvin | Carmichaels Free Methodist |
| Lois Cottle | Jefferson Methodist |
| Barry Elliot | Hewitt Presbyterian |
| Carl Hoy, Jr. | Spraggs Methodist |
| Donnis Hoy | Spraggs Methodist |
| Paul Jeffries | Jefferson Methodist |
| Wayne Kapp | Waynesburg Methodist |
| Barb Kelley | Jefferson Methodist |
| Buck Kiel | Pine Bank Methodist |
| Al Kirby | Spraggs Methodist |
| Virginia Logan | Spraggs Methodist |
| Barb Morris | Oak View Methodist |
| Shirley Neely | Pine Bank Methodist |
| Freda Pyle | Jefferson Methodist |
| George Pyle | Jefferson Methodist |
| Joe Roebuck | Washington Street Methodist |
| Mary Jane Semonick | Jefferson Methodist |
| Otis Shaffer | Great Bethel |
| Don Wilson | Hewitt Presbyterian |
| Jerry Wilson | Jefferson Methodist |
| Darlene Wright | Carmichaels Free Methodist |