| 2011-2012 | |
| SENIOR PLAYERS | |
| Joseph G. Conklin Memorial Award | |
| (Awarded to Players who turn age 70 during the season) | |
| Ruth Bungard | Crabapple Community |
| Barb Morris | Oak View Methodist #1 |
| Otis Shaffer | Glad Tidings Assembly of God |
| Dartball Players: Age 70 and Over | |
| Doris Braun | Pine Bank Methodist |
| Dorothy Cheek | Crabapple Community |
| Lois Cottle | Jefferson Methodist |
| Lou Doutt | Oak View Methodist #2 |
| Frank Farley | Bethlehem Baptist |
| Helena Gallentine | Crabapple Community |
| Jim Hawkins | Waynesburg Methodist |
| Mary Hawkins | Waynesburg Methodist |
| Carl Hoy, Jr. | Spraggs Methodist |
| Donnis Hoy | Spraggs Methodist |
| Miles Hupp | Bethlehem Baptist |
| Wayne Kapp | Waynesburg Methodist |
| Barb Kelly | Jefferson Methodist |
| Al Kirby | Spraggs Methodist |
| Bill Logan | Spraggs Methodist |
| Virginia Logan | Spraggs Methodist |
| Jim Mooney | Fairall Methodist |
| Shirley Neely | Pine Bank Methodist |
| Freda Pyle | Jefferson Methodist |
| George Pyle | Jefferson Methodist |
| Mary Semonick | Jefferson Methodist |
| Lucy Stickovich | Jefferson Methodist |
| Jerry Wilson | Jefferson Methodist |
| Jim Wood | Bethlehem Baptist |